Friday, 29 April 2016

Record Store Day

A couple a Saturdays ago I popped down to my local record shop to hear some music and browse through the racks of LPs which were loaded with mainly pop and rock music. There were some blues and jazz records available. I was not tempted to buy anything as I got the impression that the record labels were cashing in.

Yes, it is nice to hold a record cover in your hand and feel the weight of the vinyl and quite often the covert art is spectacular. However, it is the quality of the music that matters both artistically and technically. The music enthusiast has little control over the artistic content except by not buying a disliked artist.

However, from a technical viewpoint the music lover has a really broad choice. Most of the LPs will be available on CD or "on-line" sources. A well mastered CD will always sound better than its LP equivalent. The arguments about dynamic range hardly hold water. Most rock and pop music is recorded and mastered with very little dynamic range compared to orchestral works. Of course there are exceptions such as the Pink Floyd. The Beatles used compressed dynamic range to artistic effect.

You really are better off playing a CD if you you want to hear High Fidelity sound reproduction of any genre of music. The sound reproduction equipment needs to be good however.  A good set up should not cost you an arm and a leg. A thousand pounds should be able to buy a good CD player, Amplifier and Speakers - modern technology works wonders.

CD s are not plagued by pops, clicks, hisses and rumble or wow and flutter. They reproduce the music as it was recorded on the master tape. I never listen to classical music or acoustic folk on an LP.

You may well ask why bother buying and listening to an LP. I do it for a bit of fun playing a Beatles record on a turntable brings me back to my teens. If I want to hear the Beatles in their full glory then I play the modern digitally remastered versions.

Many of the new converts to vinyl agree with me, as 48% of people who buy LPs don't play them. They just look at the cover whilst playing the digital version by you tube or digital downloads. Some people pin the LP to a wall and gaze at it whilst playing the music from digital sources. 7% of LP buyers do not have a a record player at all!

I appeal to all those who love music to actually play their LPs; a turntable is not that difficult to set up and you can buy a decent one for around two hundred and fifty quid. Some turntables have the necessary pre-amp built in. Many modern amplifiers also make provision for pre-amplification. There is nothing to be frightened of when you play an LP. You just have to be careful when dropping the needle and don't play your LPs at a party. There is a slight difference in sound to the CD or MP3 equivalent because the LP itself adds a little harmonic distortion which changes the quality of the sound. If I were to be pedantic then I would consider LPs not to be High Fidelity or " High Definition"- but it is probably best not to continue with this line of reasoning.

Audio cassettes are making a comeback; I have got three players but I only use the one in my older car. I cannot bring myself to use an MP3 player with an adapter. Other than in the car I see audio-cassettes as being a pain in the neck. I have digitised any recordings  that I cannot source on CD. I have often bought audio cassettes that have survived only three or four replays. However I have got one cassette that is nearly thirty years old and it is indestructible - it is all very random. Some artists are releasing new material on this medium.

Amongst all the LPs on Record Store day I saw a young man fingering the one lonely cassette on display. He was probably debating with himself whether to buy it or not. The music was also available on LP. I was tempted to say to him not to bother but that would have been unfair on the record shop. There are no such limitations on this blog.

Will the new desire to buy LPs and audio cassettes be a long term phenomenon? The statistics point to an "analogue" revival that will be just a short term fashion. Only time will tell; but one thing is certain digital music sound is here to stay for the foreseeable future.




Wednesday, 6 April 2016

MQA new kid on the block

I shall not be rushing to audition Meridian's MQA sytem even though there is now a lot of interest in this new method of encoding digital music files.

https://www.meridian-audio.com/news-events/meridian-audio-launches-mqa-master-quality-authenticated/


We now have "temporal blurring of transients" to deal with in our calculations. MQA is based on some scientific research which suggests that human beings can detect time differences of around 5 micro seconds and use this time difference to locate exactly where sounds are coming from. A time difference of 5 micro seconds is a very short time for an electro-chemical nerve transmission system to deal with, so I am very sceptical of the neuroscience and I would need to see absolute proof of such a claim.

I am not sure that my ears are capable of handling the extra resolution that MQA claims to provide.

I cannot for the life of me recognise any difference between between a CD music file and a "HIRES" one. Neither can any of my friends or family. I have always wanted to believe that "HIRES" improves on CD  but the placebo effect and confirmation bias have failed me. My £24 spent on the HIRES download of "Band On The Run" was a waste of money because when I converted the "HIRES" version to 16/44.1  to make a CD for the car I could hear no difference. The music itself sounds great.

I am not going to try and do a double blind comparison of the 256 kbps MP3 that I made of the same album for fear of failing. The "HIRES" version of the album does not sound better to my ears than the "LORES" versions.

I have got a 24/96 "HIRES" blu-ray version of Supertramp's "Breakfast in America"  this came along  with free a 320 kbps MP3. Once again I am reluctant to do a double blind ABX comparison for fear of failing. I have also got the vinyl LP version which has remained in very good condition with few clicks and pops and not much record hiss etc. The digital versions sound better to my ears, in a technical sense". The LP sounds slightly different but not so much different that I prefer the LP version to the digital one. This music sounds great too.

Before I buy an album digitised to MQA standards I shall need proof from a measurement point of view that this form of digital conversion is superior to CD. I will then need to satisfy myself that it sounds superior to my ears.

Many of us have heard "Time" on Pink Floyd's  "Dark Side of the Moon"  and it sounds very realistic to me either in digital or analogue form. The sound of the mechanical alarm clock always gives me a shock and it sounds exactly like the clock I used to have on my bedside table.  And what is more to the point, why should I pay thousands more for equipment and newly re-mastered recordings that can only sound very marginally better to my compromised ears? If , they sound better at all!





Wednesday, 9 March 2016

Sir George Martin and The Beatles

In many ways the death of George Martin is as sad as the deaths of John Lennon and George Harrison.

George Martin was a great musician and a great record producer. He was a generalist in the age of the specialist. He was able to succeed right across the spectrum of music.

As " The fifth Beatle" he succeed in bringing the best of popular music to the masses.

In the 1960s Hi-Fi would have been a luxury; we had to listen to The Beatles on Dansette type record players or over AM radio. There was no MP3, WAV or FLAC to worry about. HD music hyperbole did not exist. Most teenagers played back their records using sapphire needles and ceramic cartridges. They could not have cared less about linear frequency response. Wow and Flutter were every day hazards. Most amplifiers produced mains hum and distorted the music at relatively low volume levels.

The Beatles music shone through all of problems associated with the sound reproduction of the day. It was only the music that mattered and it sounded just as good then as it does today: with or without Moving Coil Cartridges, HD FLAC files or 180 gm virgin vinyl.



Monday, 1 February 2016

The Vinyl Revival is running apace

It looks like the revival of LPs is hotting up. The consumer hi-fi companies are introducing more and more turntables to the market. Panasonic is bringing out an updated model its famous Technics 1200 series complete with a modified direct drive system. You will have to pay big bucks for what is really quite old technology, and the marginal improvement to the sound might not justify the extra expense. Direct drive turntables were introduced to the market in the early 1970s.

Many manufacturers are now producing turntables with built in phono-stages and USB stages so that you can easily digitise your LPs and store the result on a computer drive.

Many of the hi-fi forums have members which pour scorn on the feature of having a phono-stage built in to the turntable.  But isn't this where it should have been in the first place? Most  modern amplifiers  no longer provide a "phono" input. Audiophiles with lots of money to throw away on specialist phono-stages never use an amplifier with a built in phono-stage, anyway.

By having a phono-stage built into your consumer deck you can connect the turntable to any integrated amplifier, powered speakers or even a mini-hi-fi or television sound bar. It's all very convenient and it is all very flexible now and that is the way it should be.

Consumer turntables now sound very good. And, because the limiting factor to quality is the LP production process itself the marginal benefits of spending thousands on a turntable probably do not justify an expensive outlay. A die hard audiophile, who loves his LP, will never acknowledge this fact. Let's face it, LPs are old technology where a diamond is scrapped against a piece of plastic at a fixed speed - it's a minor miracle that an LP can sound very good. A turntable and all its accoutrements could cost you thousands - all that to play a piece of plastic worth 10 pence.

Phono-stages have been around since the 1950s. It is easy for electronics companies to mass produce ones that work very well.

The phono-stage acts as a means of amplifying the rather weak signals generated by a moving magnet (and coil) cartridges.  The phono-stage also applies RIAA equalisation to accentuate the bass response and attenuate the treble response. Thus it reverses the equalisation applied when the master vinyl pressing plate is cut.

The circuitry to produce a phono-stage is as cheap as chips, just like the DAC circuitry found in even the most expensive CD player or network streamer. Millions of these hi-fi chips are produced in factories and all hi-fi makers benefit from the economies of scale of modern manufacturing.

One consumer electronics manufacturer is associating its turntable with high definition sound and it provides users with the means to digitise their LPs to 24/192 high definition music files. Don't be fooled by this; the LP is not high definition. LPs cannot reproduce music to a higher definition than CD. The whole process of producing an LP and playing it is flawed. What is more, 24/192 "high definition" files do not sound better than a 16/44.1 CD music file when all other factors remain equal. Double blind listening tests prove this time and time again; no one can hear a difference at safe listening volumes.

Hi-fi magazines perpetuate the myth of using high definition music files to digitise your LPs as if this was going to make the LP sound better - it won't. You can use software to remove the clicks and pops on an LP but doing this actually removes some of the music frequencies. You have made the flaws of vinyl more acceptable but you have not improved frequency response or dynamic range  by using noise removal software.

I am not suggesting that those new to LPs should throw away their vinyl and ditch their turntable. I am appealing to their sense of reason so that they can see through all the marketing hype and myths perpetuated on forums. Hi-fi magazines should know better as the vinyl revival will not lead to improved sound reproduction over CD.

I have got two turntables and my wife and I like to sit down and listen to an LP every now and then; just for old time's sake. To this end, I recently bought my wife David Bowie's Blackstar: it cost me a lot of money, £25 as compared to £10 pounds for the CD, but I got a voucher for a 320 kbps mp3 download.

When I played the record it sounded fantastic. The LP was well produced in "180 g virgin vinyl", there were no scratches and there was only one pop which I heard on one of the quiet parts of the album - of which there were few. When I played the digital version it sounded almost exactly the same. Why was that ? I used the same amplifier and speakers and I matched the volume and I also played it back in the same room. Over time the LP will wear out and it will collect minor scratches and ingrained dust, despite cleaning, so the sound will deteriorate. I shall save playing the LP for special occasions or when we feel in the mood. In the main I shall play the mp3 download. There will be no need to digitise the LP to 24/192 high definition. The download will be free of pops and clicks.

There is no doubt that the Blackstar album would have been recorded digitally and then transposed to analogue for the production of the LP.  There is nothing wrong with this and this is one of the reasons why the LP sounds so good.

The LP production process degrades the sound by introducing harmonic distortion, clicks and pops and sometimes audible wow and flutter. Playback adds further harmonic distortion and sometimes extra and audible wow and flutter too. Playback also adds surface noise to the sound reproduction just from the stylus rubbing against the plastic disc. Playback can also introduce static electricity pops and dust can land on the playing surface to introduce further hissing noises.

Despite all the hype most modern LPs will have been recorded digitally and you will not be hearing so called analogue purity.

For pop music, most of the faults of LP playback  are inaudible because the music is much louder than the surface noise. Wow and flutter can be audible though. For classical music, which usually has a much wider  dynamic range than pop, the surface noise intrudes into to the quieter sections of the performance. I cannot stand this, and for this reason I never play classical music on a turntable. I always use digital sources.

Please do not fall for all the hype and if you do not have lots of money to spend on new equipment then you might be better off sticking to CD. There is also the time overhead of setting up your turntable and making sure it runs properly. LPs can sound very good and it is great to see a mechanical device spinning your music around. But, there are many pitfalls and if you do not look after your records they will eventually sound awful.



Wednesday, 6 January 2016

HIFI sound stage

There is lots of talk on hi-fi forums and hi-fi magazines about sound stage and of course lots of it is rubbish.

A so called sound stage is created by using two or mores speakers and feeding more than one channel of music into the speakers.

We have got two ears and having two ears helps us to locate the position of a sound quite accurately most of the time. We locate a sound by hearing volume differences between our ears and by the timing differences that a sound takes to move from one ear to the other.

When we listen to an orchestra playing live we can locate the positions of the various instruments in both the lateral and vertical planes. An orchestra generally positions the violins on the left as you are facing it and the cellos and double bass instruments on the left and so on. The woodwind is generally in the middle. Our hearing and perception enable us to determine the location of the instruments with our eyes closed. But,  of course, our perception and hearing can be fooled by echoes and hall acoustics. Anyone who regularly attends orchestral concerts can verify this.

When stereo recordings became generally available in the 1950's sound engineers used recording techniques and microphone placement to generate a similar sound ,when reproducing the sound an orchestra, so that a listener could appreciate the sound stage in his living room, but of course the stereo speakers had to be placed correctly and wired correctly.


If you listen to a good recording of an orchestra through a hfi-fi quality sound system then you will be able to hear an approximate positioning of the instruments. This of course depends upon the acoustics of your listening room and your position in it. Your perceptions are assisted by an expectation bias that an orchestra always positions the instruments in a "standard"  configuration. No sound recording can achieve an exact duplication of the original sound stage.

Now to the rubbish that is spoken. If you do not have access to the original master recording you cannot verify that the sound stage from your  hi-fi  matches reality. You cannot know where the instruments where originally positioned and whether  the original master recording had a 3 dimensional sound stage or not. Modern recording techniques using electric guitars and other electronic instruments now plug the instruments directly into the recording deck so they could be positioned anywhere.

If you do not have a method of comparing the original master recording to your hi-fi then all talk about the competence of your equipment's generation of an accurate sound stage is pure conjecture. Lots of hi-fi magazines ignore this fact and make comment about the sound stage of the equipment, that they are reviewing, with a misplaced and exaggerated authority - thus they are talking out of the back of their necks most of the time. Many hi-fi forum contributors also repeat this school boy error.

All I can say is that I have a reasonable hi-fi set up and when I play an orchestral work the instrument positions more or less sound as if they are coming from the place I would expect them to, but I would be shocked if it was exactly the same as if I had attended the actual performance. This is all I can expect of the sound stage of any hi-fi equipment and this is why we will never be able to achieve absolute hi-fi reproduction. You can believe of pretend otherwise if you wish.

Wednesday, 23 December 2015

Beatles on Spotify etc

I suppose that it had to happen The Beatles are now available on Spotify and other streaming services. I sometimes use Spotify and at one time I subscribed to their full service which you can receive without adverts.  Millions of tracks are available and Spotify caters for all musical tastes. Similar services are also available on-line.

The sound reproduction is very good if you feed the stream from your computer to an external DAC and use a decent amplifier and speakers. Listening through headphones on a tablet computer or a portable phone is not such a good experience. Amplifying the headphone output of a phone or tablet is also not perfect.

If you want really good sound reproduction you are better off listening to a decent hi-fi in a quiet room  through speakers without the sound of traffic whooshing past or the "clickety clack" of a railway carriage.

With streaming services you don't need a hard drive or vinyl LPs and most of your favourite music is instantly at your disposal; and you are the DJ to play whatever music you like in any order that you like. The music is de-materialised and this is part of a hi-fi future that CDs and LPs will not be able to compete with. Of course, some people will hang onto their beloved hard copies and will sit down and enjoy their music in the living room without other distractions.

Wednesday, 21 October 2015

Listening to Hi-Fi through headphones

You can buy a decent pair of headphones for about £100. You do not need to to spend a fortune on a famous branded name which is marketed using the names of pop stars or rugby players; as you will be paying for the publicity rather than the quality of the sound reproduction.

Not so long ago I bought a cheap pair of Sennheiser 'phones for about £25 for use with Skype etc. when I plugged them into a combined DAC and headphone amplifier and listened to some CD quality music I was astonished at how good they sounded. I could hardly hear any difference between them and a pair of Audio Technica 'phones costing many times more.

The frequency response of the Sennheissers was limited to 15 KHz and those of the Audio Technica up to 45 KHz. Why could I hear very little difference in the upper range of the frequencies?

Here are some good reasons why.

My middle aged ears can no longer hear a 15 KHz tone.

There is very little music happening at 15 KHz.  The primary harmonics of most musical instruments rarely climb above 4 KHz.

LPs are usually limited to a highest frequency of 15 KHz for production reasons.

CDs perform better as far as frequency response go but only some children can hear tones above 15KHz.

"HIRES" music files can reproduce tones much higher than a CD but nobody, not even the fittest 4 year old, can hear a tone above the CD limit of 22 KHz.

The £25 Sennheiser  'phones are able to reproduce all the musical frequencies that most people can hear without noticeable distortion. They are almost perfect at reproducing Hi-Fi sound with a linear response. The Audio Technica 'phones are almost perfect too and cannot be criticised in terms of value for money.

If you are prepared to put up with the plastic construction and feel of the £25 Sennheiser 'phones and their lack of street credibility then you have got yourself a very good buy.


Headphones have advantages over listening through speakers: 

You have to pay a lot more for Speakers giving a similar sonic performance,

You hear the music unhindered by the echoes and sound absorption from your room and its furniture,

The music is closer to your ears and year can hear sonic imperfections better when you are making comparisons.

You do not disturb your neighbours when playing the music loud.

They also have disadvantages:

You could be tempted to play the music too loud and damage your ears,

They can be uncomfortable,

You never hear sounds in a natural environment so close to your ears so 'phones can feel unnatural. For this reason I rarely listen through 'phones.

Headphones can block out the sound of your surroundings and in certain situations this could be dangerous especially when crossing the road or driving - you have to be more visually aware of what is happening around you.

It is anti-social to listen to music with 'phones when you are surrounded by your family and friends.


Headphones are great for making musical comparisons , however.

The other day I was listening to some 180 and 200 gm brand new LPs and I thought it would be a great idea to make comparisons to their CD equivalents.

I heard these faults on the LPs through the headphones which I could not hear on the CD equivalent:

Noticeable rumble for the LP surface in the quiet bits of the album and in between tracks,

Noticeable hiss from the LP service on the quiet bits and between the tracks,

At elevated and uncomfortable listening levels I could hear the rumble of the turntable motor,

Clicks, pops and crackles in the quiet bits of the records,

On one of The Beatles tracks I could hear noticeable harmonic distortion possibly created by the original disc cutting or from an uneven pressing at the factory or both.

Listening through headphones demonstrates that LP sound reproduction has fundamental flaws which cannot be eliminated even with the highest quality turntables and cartridges.

All in all listening to  CD was a more pleasant experience even though the LPs still sounded quite good. It really is not a good idea to listen to LPs through headphones especially when classical music is playing. I can't for the life of me appreciate some of Audiophile claims that LP sound quality is better than CD.

When I listen to an LP through speakers, the speakers themselves and the room acoustics seem to soften the sound of LP faults. However, even though I cannot hear the rumble and hiss at normal listening volumes, I can still hear the clicks, crackles and pops on the softer parts of the music and this is with a brand new LP.

If I ignore the faults of an  LP  then the music on a brand new album does not sound substantially different to its CD equivalent. However, if I were to be pedantic then I  would opine that LP reproduction cannot claim to be of genuine Hi-Fi quality.

Comparing the sound quality of HIRES and CD quality music using headphones.

I have bought some 24/96 music from the internet and then down sampled it using DbPoweramp to CD quality. When I listen through headphones I cannot hear any difference no matter how hard I try.

When I have inverted the 16/44.1 using Audacity and then played this file back at the same time with its HIRES equivalent using a null test then I hear nothing; which proves to me that there is no audible difference between a HIRES file and a CD file - to my ears anyway.

hhttp://sdk.bongiovidps.com/2013/09/26/audio-null-test/


Headphones can be very useful tools and can expose many Hi-Fi myths.